Chapter 1

The Empty Chair

The argument itself was so minor I can barely remember how it even started. Keith was fussing with the pleats in his pants. They bulged slightly and refused to lie flat.

I teased him, nothing more than something playful and flirtatious.

“Maybe we need to cut back on the ice cream.” I laughed. “Or better yet, I can help you work it off later.”

That was it. At least, I think that was it.

The air changed immediately. The playfulness drained from the room.

His face hardened. His body went rigid. No angry words. Worse. He withdrew. Cold. Completely inaccessible.

At first, I thought he would shake it off.

He didn’t.

Without saying a word, Keith methodically undressed. He pulled back the sheets, climbed into bed, and turned away from me.

I stared at him, waiting for the punch line that never came. I laughed nervously, still hoping this was some kind of bad joke.

Was he serious?

He was.

I tried reassuring him, even apologizing, although I wasn’t entirely sure what I was apologizing for. I told him I was only teasing. The more I talked, the less difference it made.

Finally, I sat on the edge of the bed in my navy blue dress and pearls, staring at the floor.

Two words.

“You go,” he said.

I stood there for a moment, my earrings still in my hand. Then I turned on my heels and headed for the door.

Up until that moment, the evening had all the makings of a wonderful night.

By then, Keith and I were deeply focused on our careers. We both worked constantly, traveled often, and prioritized our professional lives. During the week, our schedules sometimes moved past each other like ships in the night. He traveled for business. I traveled for business. We were ambitious, disciplined, and very much absorbed in building our careers.

We were not especially social people outside of our obligations. Most of our socializing happened at holidays, family functions, or company events that required attendance. Our real enjoyment came privately, usually on golf courses far away from Chicago winters.

When the temperatures plunged below zero, we escaped whenever we could—Arizona, Florida, or Nevada. We made good use of our travel rewards, which made those escapes easier to justify and more frequent. We preferred luxury golf resorts, where the warm weather seduced us and mornings began with tee times instead of snow shovels.

One year, my company produced a beautiful PGA Golf calendar featuring twelve spectacular golf courses across the country, one featured for each month. I became obsessed with the thought of visiting as many courses as possible in the calendar. I flipped through the glossy pages, fantasizing about destinations where we could escape the Chicago winters. One Christmas, I surprised Keith with a grand trip to Arizona built entirely around two of the golf resorts showcased in the calendar. We were young, financially comfortable, and genuinely had fun together.

One night after too many martinis, Keith drunkenly wandered onto the eighteenth hole, which happened to be near our room, and peed directly into the cup. We laughed like teenagers the entire time.

Days after we returned home, we watched Tiger Woods play that exact hole on television. We howled as Tiger reached into the cup with his bare right hand to retrieve his ball—the same cup Keith had christened just days earlier.

Fun times.

My company dinner was held at an elegant resort several hours away from Chicago in a countryside setting. Everyone brought their spouses. The company reserved a block of prime suites overlooking the water. The entire weekend was designed around lavish dining and very few meetings. The company hosted the weekend as a way of thanking the sales department for another exceptional year. Revenues had exceeded all expectations, and management wanted to recognize the team responsible for that success.

There were only two women in my department at the time. Oddly enough, we were both named Claire. The other Claire and I were surrounded by men. They dressed in fitted city-slicker suits and polished shoes. Many wore heavy gold watches that glittered beneath the chandeliers as they lifted their wine glasses or gestured across the table. Some wore traditional dark business suits, while others were more adventurous—tweed jackets, beige suits, even crisp pink dress shirts that somehow looked perfectly at home among the crowd.

The men varied in personalities. Some were innately analytical. Others were naturally humorous. But every one of them was at the top of their game.

One of my favorites was a man named Avery. He arrived wearing a white linen suit. He wore his gray hair in a long ponytail that hung halfway down his back. He looked less like a corporate executive and more like a well-dressed hippie who had somehow wandered into the sales world to become wildly successful.

Avery insisted a man only needed two things in life: red meat and red wine.

When I met his wife that evening, she could have been Bo Derek’s identical twin. I’m not clear why that surprised me, but it did. They were a beautiful couple.

I was fascinated to finally meet everyone’s husbands and wives. Until then, these people had existed only as coworkers. That evening, they became husbands, wives, parents, and friends with full lives beyond the office. Some lived in architecturally desirable, sleek Chicago high-rises overlooking the skyline. Others had farms farther out in the country or mini mansions in the affluent Barrington suburb. I soaked it all in. I was still discovering Chicago, its culture, and the world that surrounded it.

I had chosen my attire carefully that night. I wore a simple, well-made navy blue dress that fell just above my knees, understated, with three-quarter sleeves and a soft scoop neckline. It was a timeless cut, the kind of dress that made me feel polished without trying too hard. Beige pumps. My hair long and naturally wavy. Around my neck were the Mikimoto pearls Keith had given me, expensive and luminous beneath the chandelier lighting.

I looked in the mirror before I left the room. I looked elegant and composed, like I belonged there. However, Keith’s behavior had unnerved me. It was bizarre. Completely out of proportion to anything I had said.

The elevator ride downstairs gave me too much time to think about it. A joke about ice cream, and my husband had taken off his clothes and gone to bed.

Who does that?

The moment I entered the dining room, people noticed Keith was missing.

“Where’s Keith?”

“Is he coming down later?”

I was bombarded with questions.

I half smiled and told them Keith had a headache and was lying down for a bit. He might join us later if he felt better. Surprisingly, the lie came out naturally, almost instinctively. That unsettled me too. I had never covered for someone before.

The dining room itself was stunning. A single impossibly long table stretched through the center of the room, covered in crisp white linen. Low arrangements of baby’s breath, tiny white daisies, and soft yellow roses ran the entire length of the table, tucked between glowing candles spaced evenly from one end to the other. The flowers were arranged low enough that everyone could see the person seated across from them. Beyond us, towering windows revealed only darkness. Inside, candlelight reflected off crystal glasses and polished silverware.

The dinner was exquisite. Lobster bisque arrived first in wide white bowls. The soup was rich and velvety, with the faint scent of sherry rising in the steam. Warm bread was passed in small silver serving bowls, offering pumpernickel, rye, sourdough, and other artisan rolls. Beside each setting were three flower-shaped pats of butter—one flavored with honey, another with chives, and the third left plain. Then the salads arrived, lightly dressed with raspberry vinaigrette.

The entrées were served with precision, each guest receiving the selection they had made in advance—grilled salmon, stuffed chicken, or filet mignon. I had chosen the filet, medium rare, and to this day I still remember how perfectly it was prepared. The outside was beautifully seared while the center remained warm and rosy. It was so tender it practically melted on my tongue.

Each plate arrived arranged like artwork, with piped mashed potatoes dusted lightly with parsley and perfectly prepared vegetables placed with delicate symmetry beside the entrée. For dessert, I ordered the crème brûlée. The caramelized sugar cracked delicately beneath my spoon, giving way to the smooth vanilla custard underneath.

Everything about the evening felt magical, refined, and perfectly paced. I was genuinely grateful for my career and the opportunities it had brought me. Companies like Bradley understood the importance of a happy sales team.

There was an old saying: “Feed your eagles.”

The top producers. The relationship builders. The people who brought in the majority of the business. Those were the employees you invested in.

The dinner carried on around me. Laughter rolled across the table. Wine glasses clinked. Conversations grew louder as the evening went on.

I refocused. Whatever was going on upstairs would have to wait.

When dinner finally ended, several of my coworkers decided to continue the night downstairs at the resort bar. By then, I had bonded with many of them, especially their wives, women I had previously known only through office stories or framed photographs on their husbands’ desks. I looked forward to seeing many of them again, whether personally or at future company functions.

I understood what the company was doing. They were keeping us connected, loyal, and motivated.

They were feeding their eagles.

I opted not to join the others for cocktails at the bar. I excused myself and said I should check on Keith to make sure he was okay.

Twenty minutes later, loud knocking rattled the hotel door, followed by laughter in the hallway.

“Claire!”

More knocking.

“Come on, Claire! We’re all going to the bar!”

“Keith! You guys coming or what?”

I froze.

Keith had not moved.

He was still lying on his right side, facing the wall exactly as I had left him. His body was curled inward, almost fetal, his hands clasped tightly between his thighs. The bedside lamp cast a dull amber glow across the room. He looked vacant. Emotionally gone.

“Come on, Claire!” someone yelled again.

I looked at Keith. Then the door. Then back at Keith.

What the hell was I supposed to do?

Was he really this furious over a little teasing?

A little overkill, maybe?

Was this some sort of punishment?

Was he sick?

Was he having a breakdown?

Should I call an ambulance?

I honestly did not know.

It was like stepping into an episode of The Twilight Zone. An hour earlier, I had been downstairs surrounded by candlelight, laughter, expensive wine, and conversations about vacations and careers. My stomach was full. I was slightly drunk. And I wanted to go downstairs and keep laughing with everyone else.

Instead, I stood in a dim hotel room staring at my husband curled toward the wall.

This was bizarre.

The knocking continued.

“Claire! Come on!”

I stood between the door and the bed. I couldn’t answer it. I couldn’t leave.

They knew I was in there.

What would I say if I opened the door? What would they think if I didn’t?

That we were fighting?

That something was terribly wrong?

That we were strange?

Eventually, the knocking stopped.

Their laughter faded down the hallway. A moment later, I heard the elevator doors open, then close.

Silence.

Keith never turned around.

He never spoke.

He never moved.

I lay awake beside him for the rest of the night with questions I could not answer.

I did not know who this man was beside me.